There's a thin line here, I think, between an artist's vision and popular demand. Clearly, George Lucas would not be where is today without the phenomenal success of Star Wars. At the same time, he is a film artist with a taste that should be respected by the legions of fanboys who demand that their every request be heeded. The folks over at the Digital Bits have it right when they mention that Anamorphic Widescreen DVD is now the industry standard, not some high-end option, and any film as important (and as visually groundbreaking) as Star Wars should be offered in it. That would be fine, had not Lucas officialy sworn off the "original edits" of the trilogy that mad him rich and famous in favour of his controversial 1997 "Special Editions" of what are now called "Episodes IV, V and VI" of his six-film Star Wars series. He's consistently, over the past ten years, described his original trilogy as flawed and worked very energetically to replace them with his new vision.
Here's where I stand on the issue: Lucas is the filmmaker. He can do what he wants with his own movies. If he wants to issue the original drafts of his trilogy in a compromised, technologically inferior edition, so be it. I won't buy it (my laserdiscs will do nicely, thanks), but that's his right. Anyhow, at a certain point, people have to get over Star Wars. Roger Ebert said in his review of Star Trek: Nemesis that he was "all done" with Star Trek. My friend and filmmaker Bulent Hasan said the same thing about Star Wars once he saw Episode III. It's time to move on.
One thing that's very "mindjack-ian" (to egotistically coin a phrase) about the whole controversy is how the internet has allowed public discourse to rise to such levels, and how things that would have, a few years earlier, been thought of as technical trivialities, have become symbolic of a proletariat struggle against the corporate elite. Or, to use other, more potent terms, the struggle of a group of Rebels against an evil Galactic Empire...
|:: posted by Ian Dawe, 5/26/2006|| Comments (0)|
Links to this post